Rolling Stone’s Top Ten Beatles Songs – Are they nuts?
Most often, “bests” lists are really “favorites” lists. But you'd think that Rolling Stone - the Bible of Rock, isn't it? - would demonstrate at least a stab at journalistic intelligence with its newly-published list of the "10 Best Beatles songs." Alas, not so. But then these are the people whose “Top Guitarists of All Time” proclaimed Jimi Hendrix the greatest guitarist in history. Anybody who thinks Jimi Hendrix was the greatest guitarist in history needs to get to rehab very soon.
An ugly truth if you’re a Beatles zealot – read: Don’t touch my sacred cow - is that some of their later efforts wear The Emperor's New Clothes. You know the ones – disjointed electronic mish-mashes, incomprehensible, drugged up lyrics, intelligentsia-anointed works of “confessional genius” and so on. Artsy songs, songs with a “deeper” meaning, songs that grate the ear rather than please the ear, but we’re supposed to accept them as works of musical genius because…well, it’s the Beatles, for God’s sake, and they can do no wrong. Ill-conceived experiments. Avant-garde wanna-beism. Amateur surrealism. Songs we’re supposed to believe are great because – well, they’re heavy, man. Why? Because the influential critics tell us – the sheeple - that they are. A Day in the Life fits squarely into this category. So does Eleanor Rigby (Yawn). So does much of the White Album. I Am the Walrus. Across the Universe. Polythene Pam. Rolling Stone is stuck in this morass of pretentious dreck.
So I’m picking the greatest Beatles songs – the ones with the unique combination of lyrics, music, and performance that are the original reasons the Beatles still continue to be called – all these years later - the greatest band of all time. I share only two choices with Rolling Stone, and I believe even those two songs were gratuitous additions for them.
But let me begin with Rolling Stone’s list, and I’ll show you why they’re idiots.
1. A Day in the Life. The Beatles recorded over two hundred songs, and Rolling Stone would have us believe that this 1967 effort from Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band is the greatest of them all. John Lennon’s drowsy stoner lyrics were based on newspaper snippets he had seen – four thousand holes in Blackburn Lancashire refers to potholes, for instance – and the normal reaction on hearing the song is “What the hell is it supposed to be about?”
The song only wakes up in the middle eight, McCartney’s Woke up, got out of bed sequence, which is a snippet of a song McCartney had that was placed into A Day in the Life because Lennon couldn’t come up with anything to fill the middle. The most famous line in the song – I’d love to turn you on - is reputedly McCartney’s also, and it caused great consternation among the establishment at the time because all the old folks thought it was a drug reference. Which, of course, it was. Screw you, mom and dad, yes, Beatles songs ARE about drugs! The song demonstrates what happens when four musicians – but I’m talking about Lennon primarily - with drug-fueled delusions of musical grandeur and unlimited studio time can do. The “symphonic” ending isn’t impressive, it’s just boring and self-indulgent. The result is an ten on the Yuck-o-Meter.
2. I Want To Hold Your Hand. Rolling Stone gets one right. The song belongs in a Beatles Top Ten. (See below)
3. Strawberry Fields Forever. Rolling Stone, please share some of whatever you’re passing around here. This dirge is another insufferable Lennon stoner song from 1967. Wikipedia calls it “one of the defining works of the psychedelic-rock genre” and I suppose I’ll have to agree with that just to shut up the people who think it is actually a decent Beatles song. The lyrics are befuddled – but wait: it must be a work of Liverpudlian genius, right? It's autobiographical, right? Maybe there will even be a hidden message in it! Highly engineered, tricked up in the studio, overproduced and manufactured more than recorded, the glutinous Strawberry Fields Forever is an ode to pretentious self indulgence. The jarring, descending glissando change in the first line – Let me take you down – makes my teeth itch. I think John Lennon was capable of great lyrics, but:
No one I think is in my tree
I mean it must be high or low
That is you know you can’t tune out
But it’s all right
That is I think it’s not too bad
Please. Of course by 1967, the Beatles and in particular John Lennon had been anointed not only spokesmen but prophets, and anything they did had to be genius, right?
4. Yesterday. McCartney’s huge success of wistful wondering and lost love. Yesterday is a great ballad, it makes musical sense throughout, and is the most covered song of all time for a reason. The only problem is, it’s not a Beatles song. The only reason the Lennon co-writing credit appears is for publishing reasons – contractually, it could not at the time be released as written and performed solely by Paul McCartney. The other Beatles were nowhere in sight when it was recorded and had absolutely nothing to do with it. But this list is about the Beatles – the group, you know - not Paul McCartney.
5. In My Life. Rolling Stone gets this one right too. See below.
6. Something. Abbey Road 1969. Years ago in Dallas I saw Frank Sinatra perform Something, and when he finished he credited it to “Lennon and McCartney.” Poor George, no respect. While Something and While My Guitar Gently Weeps are generally regarded as George’s best songs, I’ll vote for Here Comes the Sun – a refreshing, unusually structured and lovely tune from Rubber Soul. I’ve got nothing against Something, it’s a very nice song. Rolling Stone may think it’s a Top Ten Beatles tune. I don’t. I detect Dead-Beatle homage bias here.
7. Hey Jude. McCartney tune released in August 1968. Written for John Lennon’s son, Hey Jude is the Beatles’ most famous sing-a-long and is solid both melodically and lyrically. There’s beauty in its simplicity, but it demonstrates more what a deceptively great songwriter McCartney is than how great the Beatles were. I especially like the melodic line under the phrase Take a sad song – the word “song” soars up to F natural against a C7 chord, briefly 'suspending' the chord by topping it with the fourth. Lovely and unexpected. Somehow Hey Jude seems life-affirming. Let’s all of us just gather around with some flowers and sing Hey Jude and the world will be a better place. Na na na na to you too, brother. Peace. Was it one of the best ten tunes the Beatles ever recorded? Maybe, I have an open mind about it. But it doesn’t make my top ten.
8. Let It Be. Another McCartney tune, released in May 1970 after the band had broken up, and if nothing else, a fitting coda for the boys and a message to the fans to…well, just let it be, dammit. A nice song and a favorite for McCartney’s concert fans – he’s been performing it for years. Nothing wrong with it. A nice sentiment. Let it Be. Let's all mellow out. Mother Mary. Words of wisdom, you know. Fine and well, but this song is more popular for its advice than it is notable for its musicality. It's a fine McCartney song, but not a great Beatles tune.
9. Come Together. From Abbey Road , 1969. Anybody who calls this grungy throwaway one of the Beatles' greatest songs needs his walrus-gumboot-head examined. Self-indulgent, indecipherable acid-based nonsense from Lennon that I'll bet McCartney hated. Not only that, Lennon stole it from Chuck Berry and had to pay a settlement with Berry ’s music publishers. Some blistering guitar work from George is the only redeeming feature. A ripped-off piece with a harsh, druggy garage band mentality one of the Beatles greatest songs? Not in this lifetime, Rolling Stone.
10. While My Guitar Gently Weeps. George’s mystical tune from The White Album. It's been called one of the “greatest guitar songs” of all time by our friends at Rolling Stone. Far be it from me to argue with those boys, right? But I really don’t have anything against this song. I like the middle part a lot. Good for George and his I Ching. I look at the world and notice it’s turning. I look at the floor and see it needs sweeping. Blockbuster lyrics, they’re not. The fact that Eric Clapton plays the guitar solo – very nicely too, in fact – shoots it down the list for me. NOW APPEARING: The Beatles featuring George Clapton on lead guitar. Doesn’t sound quite right, does it?
If this is Rolling Stone’s Top Ten – and it is - I can wait to buy the magazine. Like forever. You can’t see the rest of the list on the Internet, though. Rolling Stone, the voice of the counterculture, has a pay wall on its web site. That’s a blessing, if you ask me. Thank you, Rolling Stone, for not subjecting us to your choices of next ninety best Beatles songs.
Now, here’s what you’ve been waiting for. This hasn’t been easy, because I loved the Beatles band and I still love Beatles songs – most of ‘em, anyway. I’m one of those people who hears a Beatles song and instantly flashes back to the time and place. There was a time I could play most of them on the piano from memory. To this day, I’ll bet you I can recall more Beatles song lyrics than you can. I was part of it. They changed my life. I’ve worn out five tee-shirts.
To begin, I scanned a list and wrote down thirty-three titles that have, for one reason or another, special attributes. Narrowing this list down to ten forced me to cut some truly great, rocking or lovely tunes (See Honorable Mentions) and was like picking your favorite children. But these aren’t necessarily my favorites – they’re the top ten BEST Beatles tunes. My favorite Beatles song, I Will, doesn’t even make the top ten BEST.
10. In My Life. From 1965’s Rubber Soul, In My Life was a song that we grew wiser with. It expressed what we knew but had not yet experienced – that there were people, places and things yet to come in our lives, and we knew that this song of looking back with wistful acceptance and abiding love for those important to us was the right way to feel. In 1965, death was seldom mentioned in popular song. But when John sang “Some are dead and some are living” it brought the message home. It was honest. The Beatles were singing about the real world of human relationships, and this is a grown-up, powerful love song that taught us something about life.
The tight three-part harmonies and backing vocals are superb – All these places have their moments – and taken apart from the music, the lyrics are pure poetry.
With lovers and friends, I still can recall
Some are dead and some are living
In my life I’ve loved them all…
The authorship of the song is in dispute, with both Paul and John claiming it. McCartney says: “I find it very gratifying that out of everything we wrote, we only appear to disagree over two songs, the other being Eleanor Rigby." Regardless of who wrote what – often, one contributed the main verse and the other the middle – the two sections blend seamlessly. George’s Martin’s baroque harpsichord solo was unheard of in a pop record at the time, and gave the song a kind of classical feel that perfectly complemented the gravitas of the lyrics. A huge, transcendent leap for the Beatles and pop music in general. For what it's worth, my guess is that Lennon wrote the bulk of it.
9. Because. From Abbey Road, a John Lennon song that blew everyone away when they first heard it. Nothing even remotely similar had come before, and the incredible originality of the song – coupled with the stunning vocal performances – make it one of the most compelling pieces of popular music ever recorded. The marriage of words and music here is absolutely perfect, and this song represents the highest standard the Beatles would achieve in the studio. The eerie, soaring vocals – triple-dubbed, there are actually nine voices singing - are hand-in-glove with the otherworldly lyrics. The harmonic shock we receive when the chord changes from C# minor in the opening verses – Because the world is round it turns me on – when it reaches the word on the song unexpectedly and almost inconceivably changes to a D# minor 7th with a flatted fifth. The voices then soar to ethereal skies. Because is a confounding, inexplicable piece of music. Nothing like that has ever been done before or since. On paper, it shouldn’t work at all. In performance, it’s a gorgeous masterpiece of the Beatles artistry.
8. If I Fell. 1964 from Something New. This seemingly simple little tune makes my list because it’s just so damned pretty. But it’s very interesting musically, breaking a few compositional "rules" and showing that Lennon and McCartney could write a sensitive love song with the best of them even in the early days. The introduction – If I fell in love with you, would you promise to be true – is in the key of D flat; but when the verse begins, the key changes to D. This is very subtle to the ear and – just a guess – is such a sophisticated device that I think George Martin may have suggested it. Lennon and McCartney hadn’t written anything quite as advanced harmonically at that time, I don't believe. The sung harmonies – including a beautiful passing F diminished chord in the verse – are perfectly executed and the message – If I fell in love you would you promise not to hurt me? – resonated with us and spoke to our young fears and excitements. But mostly, it’s just…well…a beautiful little song.
7. Hold Me Tight/It Won’t Be Long. All right, I’m cheating here but this is a top ten list, not a top eleven list. These two songs from 1963 are related, though, in that they’re both early all-out rockers that showcase the Beatles as a performing rock and roll band: Original, brash, tight and confident as hell. The tunes are performed with utter abandon and both feature call and response – Hold (hold!) Me tight (Me tight!) Tonight (tonight!) - that they did so well. Songs like this are the soundtrack of Beatlemania. Listening to them, you can understand why people went wild.
6. You Won’t See Me. This sparkling jewel typifies the huge leap the Beatles made with Rubber Soul. Pristinely impeccable and tasteful throughout, the song bounces with panache and élan. The harmonies are imaginative and sweet. The middle eight – Time after time, you refuse to even listen - is masterful. The vocal work throughout is original, enticing and full of fun. You could get drunk on this song, it's so delicious. If I could freeze the Beatles at any moment in time, it would be during their Help-Rubber Soul-Revolver period, where they emerged as songwriters and musicians of the highest caliber. Which leads me to…
5. Michelle, another ground-breaker from Rubber Soul. To this day, the harmonies transmit chills. Nobody expected the Beatles to pull a French ditty on us, and McCartney has said that he wrote the song as an arty French love song, even before he had the title or lyrics down. The sophisticated backing vocals are sublime, using a series of totally unexpected ascending diminished chords sung in harmony, probably by McCartney himself overdubbing. It all works beautifully, exotically, and it’s a flat-out wonderful bijoux of a love song. It also represented the Beatles’ acceptance by the American musical community, winning the Grammy for Song of the Year in 1966. Well-deserved.
4. Here There and Everywhere. Probably the Beatles best love song, from Revolver in 1966. McCartney dazzles with a exquisite melody line, simply but perfectly underscored. In the introduction – To lead a better life I need my love to be here – the chord change from B minor to B flat to D seventh is very sophisticated. The middle part with George’s sly chromatic counterpoint is exceptional: I want her everywhere, and when she’s beside me I know I need never care. This is a Master Class in songwriting and execution and one of McCartney’s finest songs.
3. Tell Me Why. John Lennon song from A Hard Days Night in 1964. I’ve long called this tune the quintessential Beatles song. From the opening instrumental sequence serving as a prolonged downbeat, to the completely unexpected jazz progression at the coda, Tell Me Why has all the things that made the Beatles great. Exuberance, soaring harmonies, falsetto, bluesy middle, honest feelings and expressions of love, confidence, indefatigability, and it simply rocks from beginning to end. Relentless and driving, this is early Beatles at their rocking best. John’s classic-rock, raspy chorus – Well I beg you on my bended knee, if you’ll only listen to my plea – is delivered with outrageous perfection and resolves explosively: Is there anything I can do? ‘Cause I really can’t stand it I’m so in love with you…
Listen to McCartney’s revolutionary walking bass line, George’s off-beat slash chords, Ringo’s laser-fine timing; this song is all four Beatles doing what they do best. It’s got it all. Fact: And I Love Her and If I Fell were recorded at the same session as Tell Me Why. A few years later, it would take them years to make a record.
2. I Want to Hold Your Hand from Meet the Beatles, 1963. Their first number one hit, recorded in October 1963. For many of us in America , this was the first Beatles song we heard. I remember where I was – the neighborhood Katz Drug Store in Kansas City – when it played on the jukebox in December 1963. The Beatles had me from hello – it was so fresh, so unusual, so fun, so in-your-face, and most of all, it was unlike anything ever heard before. To give you some perspective on the state of pop music in America, when I Want to Hold Your Hand hit the top of the charts in February 1964, it displaced Bobby Vinton’s There, I’ve Said It Again. Popular music was NEVER the same after this song.
Why is it a great song? Well, you could talk about the insistent, pulsing introduction that foretells something important must happen… the abrupt vocal syncopations, the hand claps, John and Paul singing in unison and harmony…George’s twangy lead guitar fills… the sexy, yet still innocent middle: And when I touch you I feel happy…inside…and the glorious, extended ending – I want to hold your ha-ha-ha-ha-nd…..The triumphant final G major chord. The utter newness of it. A true collaboration, Lennon and McCartney composed this song together at the piano, as opposed to the separate composers they would later become. If you don’t understand why this is one of the greatest songs in pop history, then…then…well, I’ll just buy you a subscription to Rolling Stone.
1. She Loves You. The Beatles Second Album, 1964. This is what Beatlemania was all about, kiddies. She Loves You is the Beatles signature song, the desert island one, the time capsule one, the one to leave on the moon, the take-me-to-your-leader one.
I hate to overuse the word, but She Loves You is the pinnacle of the Beatles joyous exuberance. It’s an explosive, happy, celebratory, delirious song. The Yeah yeah yeahs were at first considered improper by the proper British – Paul’s father suggested they change it to Yes, yes, yes! Its musical vocabulary and arrangement are shot through with quirky details and nuances that were soon to develop into trademarks of the group; their special "sound" is apparent. The sweet trio of voices… the twangy guitar licks preceding the verses…the falsetto - the juggernaut pace... the orgasmic Oooo! that drove all the little girls wild.
The Beatles unique, instinctive harmonic sense is on full display here, and the voicing gives the song much of its unique flavor. With a single solo voice, it wouldn’t have been as effective as when John and Paul split into thirds and sixths. She Loves You is another true Lennon/McCartney collaboration and incidentally a radical departure from pop songs of the day in that the singer of the song is a third person, not a protagonist in the romance.
It’s a triumphant, confidant romp with unexpected sophistication and rocking delight throughout. Who, on hearing this song, doesn’t begin to tap their foot and sing along? George Martin tried to talk them out of ending the song on the G6th chord – he thought G major would be more appropriate. But the boys knew what they wanted and got it. The way that chord hangs out after the song is over makes you want to play it again to see how they did it. One last thing – there was a time when bands could actually replicate in concert what they had done in the studio. In other words, no tricks, overdubbing, re-dos and so on. You can watch any number of live performances of the song on You Tube and hear the exact studio arrangement. What you see is what you got. Yet another thing that makes it special – just four guys making a noise that rocked the world.
Honorable Mentions:
All My Loving, Blackbird, Drive My Car, For No One, Good Day Sunshine, Got To Get You Into My Life, Help, I Will, Nowhere Man, Oh! Darling, Please Please Me, Rain, The Night Before, You’re Gonna Lose That Girl, and many others.
So Rolling Stone, have a nice life and all that. Toe-jam football, monkey finger, spinal cracker….and peace.
John Dawson
August 26, 2010
John Dawson
August 26, 2010